I can’t tell you how many times when I was an open source noob, I’d wonder what the heck the installation instructions were talking about or was frustrated because no one answered questions posted to the listserv. I suppose that is one of the reasons I thought “when I write a book on open source web applications that it will contain specific installation instructions”. Having written that book now, its not as easy as it might seem. I mean do I give step by step instruction on MySQL using the command line or MyPHPAdmin? Instruction for what OS? It is daunting for both people writing documentation and those using it.

Which bring us to the point that Kathryn Greenhill makes in comment on a post by Roy Tennant which highlights the Ed’s commentary. Open source software means that users need to take an more active role than often people are used to taking. More than once at the end of a frustrating day working to get something installed properly, I’ve gone back in and edited software’s documentation wiki or sent an email with suggested changes. Better and more thorough documentation almost always comes from a community effort.

To do this though one has to learn how to participate in an open source community. Learning how to participate is a ongoing process though because one may participate in new ways or in different communities over time. The idea though is that community members are able to build confidence over time by acquiring new skills. Case in point, there is a patch for a Drupal module I’d like to test, try and report back on. But I’ve never done that before. So I don’t know how to apply the patch, which means I’m sort of stuck until I either:

1. Go searching the internet for instructions
2. Ask someone who I know might how to do it to help me

At the moment I’m not feeling brave enough to deal with the situation. I’m nervous about the possibility of seriously messing up my test server and having to rebuild it, but I’m also afraid of looking stupid because I have to admit that I’m outside my comfort zone.

Many of the things that Ed suggest in his post help to build a larger comfortable starting point for users trying to implement open source software and participate in the community. Without that it sort of feels like you’re hanging on by your finger nails trying to do this stuff and it makes you not want to try. Everyone needs a starting point and if you’re creating open source software you have to think about starting point you are giving people to be part of your software’s community.

For my part, I’d like to see it dead easy for student to get their ILL and reserves. As easy as it is for me to get new books. Meaning if at all possible I don’t need to play games of hook my device up to my computer and load things. Cause maybe my ereader is the only thing I carry around with me.

Sitting Tweeting Griffey and DLK I remember seeing something about students and Nooks on the Barnes and Noble site. It took a minute to find NOOKStudy, which looks like a cross between an ereader application and course management software. There are some very interesting and appealing thing about it. Particularly in the vein of going where your users are. Digging through the website several possible opportunities for libraries jumped out at me. Particular the Research Online functionality which is highlight seems like an ideal opportunity for libraries to provide content to users. I could definitely seen how one could integrate the WorldCat Search API into this or even just WorldCat.org. Being able to integrate with library resources and add library material to this would be really cool.

Not long after my conversation the new issue of Library Journal came out with a series of articles on ebooks and libraries from Jason, Eric Hellman, Barbara Fister, and Char Booth. The articles are a precursor to Library Journal’s eBook Summit, which I’m keenly interested in. I hope the summit discussion raises a wide array of issues and that traditional models and workflows are questioned. Ebooks present an variety of challenges to libraries and I hope the Summit will get people to think outside the box.

After three weeks, I’m very happy. The main things I wanted to use it for work fabulous. Email, address book and calendar are slick. Since I put all my contacts into Gmail before I got the phone, I literally signed the phone into my Google Account and presto all my contacts. My Google Calendar and Gmail were just as easy. Setting it up to talk to OCLC’s Exchange server just took a few minutes of the OCLC Help Desk’s time.

I easily plugged the phone into the rental car and played music off it on my trip to upstate NY. When I neglected to bring the hotel’s address for the IDS conference, Google Maps put me on the right road in less than 2 minutes. Notes were super easy to take with GoogleDocs and I was able Tweet the conference on Twitter. On that trip I honestly didn’t need my laptop.

I also like that I can check my bank account from the phone. Plus the application for Toodledo, which I use to manage my To dos is great. Getting voicemail from GoogleVoice is also WAY easier that before. I’ve also use the web browser to look at my LibraryThing account when I’m at the used bookstore or want to recommend a book to someone and can’t remember the title. Last.fm is pretty awesome too. When I get sick of the music on the phone, I can use Last.fm to stream other music.

A few things I haven’t gotten/found a app for in the Android market yet.

• Grocery list application
• A better way/application to load and read PDF files
• ereader application to read non-B&N ebooks, particularly ones without DRM but also I’m curious if I can read Overdrive book on the Android phone. Unless someone knows how to load and read these with the Nook app

Things I know that don’t exist

• HuluPlus app or even Hulu app. The website sort of works but you can’t watch videos.
• Netflix app like the one for the iPad
• Box.net app – I use Box for storing my files. I have a Dropbox account but have been using Box for a while and like it. The fact they don’t have an app is annoying and combined with a couple other things may cause me to switch permanently to Dropbox.

Also I’m very interested in QR codes. I saw one on a restaurant door yesterday and was curious where it led to but didn’t know how to read it with the phone. Do I need a particular app or what? I’m also disappointed with the crippled version of Skype that I can use to call people but it uses my cell minutes and I can’t use it via wi-fi. That’s just plain stupid.

I’m sure I’ll find more uses down the road but now I’m still a novice user trying to figure out the basics.

Option 1 – Play it through my speakers had hope my USB headset picked it up
Option 2 – Find a program that let me send the audio from Quicktime to WebEx and/or Skype and also allowed me to pipe my voice through as well.

While Option 1 would work, it is klunky and yucky. So I decided for option 2. I knew that I’ve read about people recording Skype calls so that they had both their voice and the voice of the person they were talking to. Lots of people doing this used Soundflower or Audio Hijack Pro. So I assumed something like this might work for my purposes. Audio Hijack Pro cost money (there is a trial version) and it also provides recording capabilities, which I didn’t need. Soundflower on the other hand is open source and does exactly what I hoped. It allows you to take the audio output from one program, send it to Soundflower, then use Soundflower as the audio input for another program. Simply put, awesome.

The only downside is that I could make Soundflower the input for Skype, which would get the video is sound or I could make my headset the input. An annoyance but not a deal breaker. What I did was set Skype’s input to my headset while I was talking, then to Soundflower when I was playing the video, then back to the headset when the video was done. I don’t think that was noticeable to the participants. It was an inconvenience that required more work on my part but it was workable. Maybe if I had more time I would have found a way to avoid this but all in all this solution worked.

Anyone out there know how to overlay my headset input and Quicktime audio and push them back to Skype?

It seems that Kobo books are EPUBs that use Adobe Digital Editions DRM. The same DRM that the Overdrive public library books use. I reasoned that if I could read the Overdrive books on the Nook that I SHOULD be able to read the Kobo and Borders books. All I had to was try it out. Luckily I was able to find a free ebook on the Kobo site, which I was able to successful download and use on the Nook. Bolstered by this success I purchased an ebook and was able to successfully load it on the Nook with Adobe Digital Editions. Yippee! The big downside with these is that they live in the My Documents section of the Nook, separate from all the Barnes and Noble ebooks. Also you can’t make the purchase from the Nook itself. Neither of these are deal breakers for me and since Kobo sometimes has good deals, I’m now subscribed to their RSS feed to see what new stuff might come up. I’ve already gotten two books for free that I’d like to have so I’m pretty psyched.

I’d love it if Amazon would let me buy ebooks that would work on the Nook. I have an Amazon credit card and get reward gift certificates from that. Because I can’t use this for ebooks I’ve been using a different card that I can get Barnes and Noble gift certificates as rewards instead. It seems that Amazon might be shooting itself in the foot with me since there ereader didn’t impress me. Yet another reason by content and container need to be decoupled. Which is why the Kobo approach seems to make sense. Only time will tell if they are successful. Maybe Barnes and Noble should follow suit too. After all their reader appears to work with EPUBs already and people could then use their content on any of the Kobo devices.

When I got home I took the Air to the local Apple Store to have them fix it. Since it was out of warranty, I figured I’d be paying the piper and having to cough up for it myself. I literally was home for less than 24 hours between ALA and my vacation. So I needed to drop it off quickly and come and get it after my vacation. When I got the Apple Store it was of course incredibly busy. Fortunately an associate came up quickly and asked me what I needed. I explained the situation and was able to “Quick Drop” my Air in under 10 mins. Less than 24 hours later the store called to break the bad news – that because of the way the hinge is designed it wasn’t a simple easy repair. Ack. The good news was that they would perform the repair for free. AWESOME. Within 72 hours of dropping the Air it was fixed and ready for me to pick up.

This isn’t the first time Apple has given me free service. When my Airport Express went on the fritz, they replaced that for free as well. Both of these experiences leave me with warm and happy feelings towards the Apple Store. This is the kind of experience that will assure that I continue to buy something new from Apple on nearly an annual basis.

I’ve posted about the fact I bought a Nook back in May and one reason for buying the Nook was that it DID work with Overdrive ebooks. My experience with it and Overdrive ebooks has been pretty darn good. Since May I’ve read dozen ebooks via Harris County Public Library’s Overdrive subscription. That’s at least $80 worth of reading if all those books are paperbacks. Its also a dozen books I don’t have to resell or find a home for if I’d purchased them. Once I figured out how to get the books on Nook it was really simple and I could place holds and load books from pretty much anywhere on either my desktop or laptop. My process is pretty simple. Find what I want (little clunky), either check it out or place a hold. Download to computer, put on Nook. When I’m done “return it” and check out the next thing. Its pretty easy. There are a couple places for improvement in the process.

1. I want to be able to perform the find and check out process natively from the Nook. No computer necessary. Mostly because I don’t want to have to have my computer with me to get new books. This is particularly important to me when I’m traveling for pleasure and don’t want to be tempted to do any work.
2. Better searching would be a an improvement. Sometimes the Overdrive searching is just dumb. It is not fault tolerant when it comes to how you put in author names. While the catalog has better searching, the limiting and browsing isn’t what I’d like it to be to find what I want. So I use the Overdrive site and deal with its searching quirks. As a result, I do lots of browsing for new stuff and I keep track of what the library has as an ebook that I want using the Overdrive wishlist and LibraryThing. (Side note an RSS feed of new ebooks in a particular genre would be awesome).

Even without these changes, I feel quite good about my ebook experience with Overdrive and the Nook as a device. Ebook experiences can be good ones. However, whether or not users have a good experience is often directly tied to the relationship between the content provide and the devices provider.

So in contrast, I found the Overdrive App for iPod and iPhone a complete waste of time. Mostly because it is ugly and I can’t figure out how to make it work. But even more so because I can’t get all the content available on the iPod. So while I can get some audio things, I can’t get books, or videos. Just didn’t really feel like it was worth my time. It isn’t Overdrive’s fault solely nor Apple’s. Instead its like oil and water, they don’t mix because IMHO, the parties are looking out for their own interests more than that of their consumers. The Overdrive Apple thing isn’t unique, Overdrive doesn’t work on Kindle and Kindle content doesn’t work on Nook.

Ultimately, in my mind this almost always comes down to DRM; and content providers and devices providers supporting different kinds of DRM and formats. People are either held hostage by the device they have to particular content suppliers or held hostage by the content provider they want to do business with to have a particular device. Libraries need electronic media formats that are device and content provider independent. Otherwise we, like users, will be forced to make imperfect choices.

And as Sarah points out, the situation doesn’t stop people from hacking content anyway. Just Google a little and you’ll find ways to strip the DRM from various things. I’m quite happy to pay but I want it to work right on the device of my choice. After all, we have three Macs, two PCs, 3 iPods, a iPod Touch, iPad, Nook and soon an Android phone at our house. So we definitely need device and platform independence.

The sad thing is that the user experience, could and should be a good one. It doesn’t need to be this hard or frustrating. To me that is the most frustrating thing.

On the surface this doesn’t seem like it should be that big of a deal. Just pick it up and move it. The problem is that all my urls point to addresses which sit in /wordpress, which is where my blog has always been located. What does that mean? Well to fix it I’m going to have to spend some time playing with rewrite rules and regular expressions to remedy the situation. Big sigh.

My other option is to install WordPress in the site root and have that site be sort of empty and install this blog back into the wordpress directory like it was a sub-blog. While it is simpler, it isn’t an elegant solution in my opinion. Rewrite rules IMHO are a better choice, even if they take longer to make sure they are working right.

Luckily, I don’t have a super burning need to move my blog to the domain root. I mostly would like to do it so I can have more than one blog on the domain, without having multiple WordPress installs. Right now I have multiple installs for some test sites of mine. Getting rid of that would be a good idea, but its going to take some work that I’m not particularly motivated to do right now. Plus, I don’t really need my test sites anymore so I could just as easily pitch them as incorporate them into an single install. So we’ll see what happens based on my available cycles and my motivation level.

In the meantime, the new WordPress is snazzy looking and I’m eager to see what new features I can find besides the multi-blog capabilities.

Nearly one month later I’m very happy with my decision. Much of my satisfaction comes from the fact that I can use my libraries ebooks on the Nook. I’ve borrowed and read nearly a dozen ebooks. Its so easy and the collection that the library has is quite good.

For me this is a huge bonus. I like to read a lot and don’t want to spend my entire disposal income on books. I’ve always borrowed from the library and having the Nook continues to let me do that. It is beyond unfortunate that other ereaders (in particular the iPad) don’t work with library ebook technologies. Considering the Apple Adobe relationship and the fact that most ebooks are DRM’d via Adobe’s software, I’m not optimistic that this will change.

My love for borrowing ebooks doesn’t mean I don’t purchase books though. I have a very small but growing collection. I’m using Calibre to load non-DRM’d content including a bunch of short stories that I got from some of my favorite authors’ websites and content from Project Gutenburg.

All and all I’m feeling good about the decision. It certainly is easier than trying to jam 3 books in my carry on and 4-6 more in my suitcase. Also no late fees, borrowed ebooks just stop working when their check out period is up.

The Guardian also has an API and Movie and Book Reviews, but I haven’t figured out the most efficient way to get at those reviews from a title in a library record. I don’t seem to be able to search with the appropriate limits to just get reviews about a particular movie. I always seem to get a cluster of other stuff that also has those keywords but isn’t the review of the movie I want. I’d appreciate any ideas folks who’ve worked with the Guardian API are willing to share in the comments.

I’m very keen on getting metadata about films so another API which I found and have become interested in is the Netflix API.What I really want is to be able to put indicators about what awards a film has won as well as reviews. In addition, I had the idea of adding to an Identities screen, awards which actors, actresses, directors etc have won.

One of the biggest difficulties with films is making sure I get the right film. Title works reasonably well, but since films get remade, it is necessary to check the year to make sure one is linking to the appropriate version. I’m lucky because the New York Times Movie Review API includes a field for DVD Release Date which I can compare to the publication date in the MARC record. It would be SO much easier if the New York Times used a standard identifier of some sort though.

A while ago a colleague brought up the mashing up popular music data like top hit charts with library catalog data. So I did a web search and found the Billboard API. The API provides developer level access to the data about what songs have appeared on the Billboard charts, past and present. It can be searched to see if a particular song or artist was ever on the Billboard charts for a particular date range. One thing that is sort of disappointing is that I don’t see any way in the documentation to search for if a particular album appeared on a particular chart or any chart, which is sort of too bad. Digging around their site I also found that their charts also have RSS feeds available which is nice. Both Rhapsody and Last.fm have web services but Pandora does not.  Another possible source of metadata about music is MusicBrainz.

Its interesting to think about all these information sources as possible ways to enhance library interfaces. It takes time to work through the different APIs and find other sources of data but I think that libraries to think about what other data sources can be used to provide users with a better UI experience.